Breaking Out of the Spiral of Silence

The Big Picture – 
By Glynn Wilson

WASHINGTON, D.C. — It’s been 13 years since I first wrote a column from here. It was 2005 and I was house sitting for a close friend in Silver Spring, Maryland. The newspaper and magazine freelance business had already started to tank in the early days of the internet and blogging, so I went independent and started publishing on the web almost exclusively. Even before the Bush Great Recession hit in 2007-2008 and everybody started getting on Facebook in about 2009, it was already clear that newspapers were in real trouble.

GW FBMug2 2 - Breaking Out of the Spiral of Silence

Glynn Wilson

The New York Times, which I had worked for out of New Orleans and Birmingham from 2002 through the winter of 2005, had already started laying off reporters and cutting back on paying freelancers. The tech team tried putting up a paywall in 2005, but it failed to deliver enough paying subscribers to make up for the losses in print and digital advertising, so the Times got rid of it in 2007. The Birmingham News and other Newhouse papers were still trying to charge $1 for people to print out and read an article back then. No one was buying.

The future looked bright for the web, but we had to figure out how to build the economy for it. When the hacker/programmer in Homewood got my new site up and live, The Locust Fork News-Journal, I wrote this first Sunday column: Original Cowboy Blog.

It was sort of like a Brave New World back then, with lots of possibilities but also pitfalls. No one really knew what would happen to news and democracy, but we had great hopes even as Bush was crashing the global economy with deregulation.

Luckily for us, Barack Obama got elected to the United States Senate in 2004 and was sworn in in January 2005, and as depicted in one of the movies on the financial meltdown, was there in the room to carve out a plan to bail out the banks in 2008 even as Bush walked out of the room. The weak-minded president just couldn’t handle all the technical talk about the global economy, but at least he went along with the plan Obama crafted to save us from an international depression.

To this day most people don’t know how close we came to the utter collapse of the economy. If ATM machines had stopped working, we would all have been eating shoe leather like they were in Birmingham back in the 1920s even before the Great Depression of the ’30s. The gen-Xers and Millennials who took part in the Occupy Wall Street movement had bad timing and a nearly total lack of knowledge of history.

But of course like kids everywhere, you couldn’t tell them anything. By then the narcissist only opinions matter era had already begun, which just morphed into hyperdrive with the era of alt-facts thanks to Fox News, Facebook, Steve Bannon, Breitbart News and Donald Trump’s Twitter campaign for president.

We are now living in a world where a president of the United States is running the country on alt-facts, where the fake right-wing, conservative, Republican view of the world on Fox News is substituted for reality. It’s not just political “infotainment” anymore. Major national and international decisions are being made on the basis of what Sean Hannity says on Fox and Bannon says in Trump’s ear.

And unlike what many intellectuals and liberals on the political left see as an insane, weak-minded accident, there is an evil plan behind all of this to divide and conquer. We still don’t know the full extent of Trump’s collusion with Russia, and may never know if Trump is really able to get away with firing special counsel Robert Muller and pardoning himself.

But Trump’s recent comments about getting Russia back in the G-7 to make it the G-8 again is certainly telling. No collusion? Then why is Trump pimping for Russia, still? Trump torpedoes G7 effort to ease trade spat, threatens auto tariffs.

As New York magazine recently reported: Trump Is Fulfilling Russia’s Dream of Splitting the Western Alliance.

Remember why Russia was expelled from the G-8 “after invading and seizing territory from its neighbor, among other aggressive actions — including murdering people overseas, menacing other neighbors and, not incidentally, committing cybertheft against the Democratic Party as part of its operation to help elect Trump.”

A key line: “The rise of Donald Trump has been met with a persistent strain of denial.”

This denial continues, and literally resembles a similar phenomenon in Germany from the 1930s. Many people in a number of countries, including the United States, thought they could continue to negotiate with Adolph Hitler (including the Bush family). Many years later, after all the atrocities of World War II were studied by academics, German political scientist Elisabeth Noelle-Neumann came up with a theory to explain why people remain silent in the face of crisis. It came to be known as the spiral of silence theory.

Now you can argue that the Wikipedia version of this story is shallow, for sure, but here is the lay person’s summary just so the average news reader in the U.S. and Alabama can begin to grasp what’s really going on.

This theory “stipulates that individuals have a fear of isolation, which results from the idea that a social group or the society in general might isolate, neglect, or exclude members due to the members’ opinions. This fear of isolation consequently leads to remaining silent instead of voicing opinions. Media is an important factor that relates to both the dominant idea and people’s perception of the dominant idea. The assessment of one’s social environment may not always correlate with reality.”

If that sentence doesn’t shake you to the core and make you want to march in the streets and financially support a better press on the web, I don’t know what will. I have been working my fingers to the bone for 13 years for very little money to try to get people to understand how important this is. I understand many people in my home state of Alabama are too afraid of their conservative friends, neighbors and co-workers to share these links on Facebook.

But let me ask you what is worse. Starting an argument with your friends, family members and co-workers — or a fascist dictator taking over the United States of America and crashing the global economy again for political purposes and to take over the country? This is NOT some partisan exaggeration. It is happening right before our very eyes every single day.

I don’t know how many horrible disasters it will take to wake people up. Even Al Gore said it will take a crisis. How much of a crisis? Look around. Will it take shutting down the ATMs where people can’t get access to their money? Will it take a nuclear war with Iran and/or North Korea? Will it take sea levels rising to a point where it creates beach front property on the Creek reservation in Atmore?

Wake the fuck up people and get involved. We can’t just save the world on Facebook. Democracy takes real American objective journalism, news steeped in the facts, not alt-facts on TeeVee. And you can’t get that for free.


Brother, can you spare a dime?

NAJlogo 1 - Breaking Out of the Spiral of Silence

We hope you enjoyed this article.

Before you continue, I’d like to ask if you could support our independent journalism as we head into one of the most critical news periods of our time in 2024.

The New American Journal is deeply dedicated to uncovering the escalating threats to our democracy and holding those in power accountable. With a turbulent presidential race and the possibility of an even more extreme Trump presidency on the horizon, the need for independent, credible journalism that emphasizes the importance of the upcoming election for our nation and planet has never been greater.

However, a small group of billionaire owners control a significant portion of the information that reaches the public. We are different. We don’t have a billionaire owner or shareholders. Our journalism is created to serve the public interest, not to generate profit. Unlike much of the U.S. media, which often falls into the trap of false equivalence in the name of neutrality, we strive to highlight the lies of powerful individuals and institutions, showing how misinformation and demagoguery can harm democracy.

Our journalists provide context, investigate, and bring to light the critical stories of our time, from election integrity threats to the worsening climate crisis and complex international conflicts. As a news organization with a strong voice, we offer a unique, outsider perspective that is often missing in American media.

Thanks to our unique reader-supported model, you can access the New American journal without encountering a paywall. This is possible because of readers like you. Your support keeps us independent, free from external influences, and accessible to everyone, regardless of their ability to pay for news.

Please help if you can.

American journalists need your help more than ever as forces amass against the free press and democracy itself. We must not let the crypto-fascists and the AI bots take over.

See the latest GoFundMe campaign here.

Don't forget to listen to the new song and video.

Just because we are not featured on cable TV news talk shows, or TikTok videos, does not mean we are not getting out there in search engines and social media sites. We consistently get over a million hits a month.

Click to Advertise Here

NAJ 2024 traffic Sept - Breaking Out of the Spiral of Silence

0 0 votes
Article Rating
4 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
S. D. Yana Davis
S. D. Yana Davis
6 years ago

Superb piece, Glynn. Thanks for being alive and being a real journalist at a time like this.

Will
6 years ago

Great insight Glynn!

Combating the spiral of silence means getting out and meeting your fellow resisters! Find events and get involved. I believe meeting like minded people who are willing to speak up and speak out for real change is the key factor for success in november! Roll Tide! = #BlueWave2018! #HD62

Susan Warley
Susan Warley
6 years ago
Reply to  Glynn Wilson

Hey Glynn! So glad you have been in the trenches all this time while some of us (me, really) went underground, took too much Zoloft, and wondered how to climb back into the insanity without getting sucked into the vortex again.

I have been especially thrilled by things like the “On the Media” interview with Sy Hersch that aired on NPR last night and this morning. Sometimes it feels like the forces are in alignment again and that we can make rather large shifts in consciousness upward rather than the reverse.

Anyway, I am alive and well on Dauphin Street and glad to see you and my old friend David Underhill still penning the best stuff I wish I had said. Still essentially an optimist, but with three decades of experience since I fled the Gingrich revolution for Alabama in 1997, I will try to find ways to support your excellent work.